Aston Villa’s Champions League hopes were dramatically dashed at Old Trafford, as they suffered a controversial 2-0 defeat to Manchester United.
The turning point came in first-half stoppage time when goalkeeper Emiliano Martínez was sent off for bringing down Rasmus Højlund outside the area following a poor backpass from Matty Cash.
Villa, who would have qualified had they secured even a draw—with Newcastle losing at home to Everton—played the entire second half with 10 men and suffered from a pair of highly contentious decisions.
Key Incidents:
Red Card:
Martínez was dismissed for denying a clear goalscoring opportunity, forcing Unai Emery to sacrifice Marco Asensio for substitute goalkeeper Robin Olsen.
Disallowed Goal:
Moments before United’s breakthrough, Morgan Rogers thought he had given Villa the lead, but the referee ruled that he had kicked the ball from Altay Bayındır’s hands. Crucially, the whistle was blown before the ball crossed the line, nullifying any VAR review.
United’s Goals:
76’ – Amad Diallo scored with a looping header from Bruno Fernandes’ diagonal cross.
90+4’ – Christian Eriksen, on his Old Trafford farewell, converted a penalty after Ian Maatsen fouled Diallo.
Emery Fumes as Villa Fall to Europa League
Unai Emery was visibly livid on the touchline, first over the disallowed goal and later the penalty decision.
Aston Villa, who had reached the Champions League quarter-finals this season, will now play in the Europa League in 2025/26.
Newcastle Squeeze Through Despite Everton Defeat
Despite a 1-0 home defeat to Everton, Newcastle United sealed Champions League qualification, thanks to Villa’s loss.
Carlos Alcaraz’s 65th-minute header gave Everton the win, and St James’ Park was riddled with tension until confirmation of United’s win filtered through.
Newcastle finish 5th, with the Premier League receiving five Champions League spots due to strong European coefficients.
The achievement caps a landmark season where Eddie Howe’s side lifted the Carabao Cup – their first major trophy in 70 years.
Final Outcome:
Newcastle United: Champions League (5th place)
Aston Villa: Europa League (6th place)
Both clubs look forward to European adventures next season.
